Test your multi team negotiation skills - with Harvard Harborco

Harborco Role play to learn your negotiation behavior

Denise Madigan, Thomas Weeks, and Lawrence Susskind

Six-party, multi-issue, scoreable negotiation among representatives of a port developer, labor union, environmental coalition, other regional ports, governor's office, and department of coastal resources over a proposal to build a new deep-water port

 

Harborco is a consortium of development, industrial, and shipping concerns interested in building and operating a deepdraft port. It has already selected a site for the port, but cannot proceed without a license from the Federal Licensing Agency (FLA). The FLA is willing to grant Harborco a license, but only if it secures the support of at least 4 of 5 other parties: the environmental coalition, the federation of labor unions, a consortium of other ports in the region, the Federal Department of Coastal Resources (DCR), and the Governor of the host state. The parties have several issues to negotiate before deciding whether or not to approve the port, including the types of industries that will be be permitted to locate near the port, the extent to which environmental damage be mitigated, the extent to which organized labor will be given preference in hiring during construction and operation of the port, the amount of any federal financial assistance to Harborco, and the amount of any compensation to other ports in the region for potential economic losses?

 
3 favorite thumb_down thumb_up 0 comments visibility_off  Remove from Watchlist visibility  Add to Watchlist
 

Outline/structure of the Session

MECHANICS:

This game is best played with 12 people (2 per role) although 6 people also works. A game manager is needed to conduct periodic votes and to answer questions. Game instructions require at least 30 minutes to read; more preparation is helpful. Negotiations require a minimum of 2 hours. However, the more time allowed for negotiation, the better.

 

 

TEACHING MATERIALS:

For all parties:

  • General Instructions

 

Role specific:
Confidential Instructions to the Negotiator for:

  • Harborco
  • Other Ports
  • Environmental League
  • Union
  • Federal DCR
  • Governor

 

Teacher’s package (67 pages total):

  • All of the above
  • Teaching Note
  • Game Review Chart

Learning Outcome

MAJOR LESSONS:

  • When the game is played by several groups at the same time, the comparison of outcomes is instructive. Typically, some groups will reach agreement and some will not. Very few groups will reach unanimous (6-way) agreement.
  • Players are exposed to elementary utility analysis in the point scoring scheme. The importance of pre-negotiation analysis in evaluating options is illustrated. The players can then explore how and why different negotiating strategies led to different outcomes.
  • Multi-issue, multi-party negotiations tend to involve the formation of coalitions–especially blocking coalitions. This game provides an instructive context for exploring coalition strategies.
  • Parties that reveal their true interests do not necessarily do better than those who remain silent or bluff. The advantages and disadvantages of revealing all one’s concerns are illustrated in this game.
  • Pareto-superior and Pareto-inferior agreements are illustrated by the scores.
  • When 12 players play the game (2 per role) they have an opportunity to explore the special difficulties of negotiations involving non-monolithic parties.
  • The need for a neutral “process manager” of some sort is also illustrated, as the parties struggle to structure their discussions.
  • The advantages of caucusing can be explored. In some cases, players will initiate caucuses; in others, they will avoid private caucusing.

 

Target Audience

Product owners, Scrum masters, leaders

schedule Submitted 1 year ago

Comments Subscribe to Comments

comment Comment on this Proposal

  • Liked David Koontz
    keyboard_arrow_down

    David Koontz - Cultivating Collaboration - Simulation of Pair Programming via Tangrams Exercise

    90 mins
    Workshop
    Beginner

    It’s said that two heads are better than one, in reference to problem solving. We will use Tangram puzzles to simulate this experience, and via structured debriefs of these exercises, discover the powerful behaviors of awesome collaboration, and the negative warning signs of poor collaboration.

     

    We will jump right into simulation exercises, come prepared to have FUN and learn by doing.

    No lecture - if you want a lecture… go here: http://lmgtfy.com/?q=+collaboration+pair+programming+lectures

    References will lead you to the science behind collaboration - if you wish to know more.  Seems like an example right about now might be helpful,  wish I had a chicken tangram....

    Tangram example of a chicken

  • Liked Michael Nir
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Michael Nir - The Two Dollar Game - an MIT game

    Michael Nir
    Michael Nir
    President
    SAP Labs
    schedule 1 year ago
    Sold Out!
    90 mins
    Workshop
    Intermediate
    The Two Dollar Game is the opening game in Negotiation and Conflict
    Management.It was developed in order to illustrate some basic tools of negotiation theory, in the simplest possible game.
  • Liked Lisa Sieverts
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Lisa Sieverts - The Hello Game

    Lisa Sieverts
    Lisa Sieverts
    Owner
    Facilitated Change
    schedule 1 year ago
    Sold Out!
    30 mins
    Talk
    Beginner

    Using one of Thiagi's Frame Games, we'll run through the Hello Game, which is a highly interactive way to begin a workshop. The Hello game serves the purpose of collecting useful information from the group, such as experience and expectations, in a fast and collaborative way.

  • Liked Yuval Yeret
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Yuval Yeret - Using a Kahoot Online Survey/Quiz as a facilitation technique to spark engagement and open the space

    90 mins
    Workshop
    Beginner

    In recent years I've been using Kahoot and other similar techniques to help me facilitate agile workshops and sessions all the way from the team level to the enterprise scale (and even conference talks). 

    Kahoot is an awesome online Quiz/Discussion/Survey tool that is free and easy to both setup and use. I use it to assess knowledge in order to focus learning, assess level of maturity in order to focus coaching, as a fun quiz to generate some laughs, an estimation game, as a safe way to gauge confidence level in plans drafted in a workshop as well as to run audience surveys during conference keynotes or as a quiz that drives a learning session. 

    In this workshop we will experience the whole game design/use cycle - from identifying the need/purpose all the way through game design to actually experiencing play.

    We will review the thinking behind some of the games I designed and use on an ongoing basis.

    Then you will work in teams to create and experience your own games addressing your own needs. 

     

  • Liked Mariya Breyter
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Mariya Breyter - The Feedback Game

    Mariya Breyter
    Mariya Breyter
    Agile Coach
    Consultant
    schedule 1 year ago
    Sold Out!
    90 mins
    Demonstration
    Advanced

    Feedback is vital to our personal and professional growth. It helps create self awareness, identify areas of strength, and areas of opportunities. However, in our everyday life we do not find enough time to provide or ask for feedback. We frequently do not know how to respond to feedback and start explaining our motives or take it personally, while the only correct answer to feedback is "thank you". This game provides an opportunity to give and receive feedback in a positive and non-confrontational way. It can be used for alignment and team building, or as a format for retrospectives. This is my original game that I practices with multiple teams in several organizations, and everywhere we found a lot of value (and fun) in it.

    We will be playing two games during the session: a collaboration game (which is a learning experience by itself), and then will use my original feedback game to give each other feedback as a retrospective. What is most fascinating, both are silent games. The power of silent communication is yet to be understood and quantified, and these two games will show how powerful silent communication may be and how it can create thoughtful and respectful atmosphere on the team.

     

     

  • Liked Paul Wynia
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Paul Wynia - Mob Programming with LEGO®

    90 mins
    Workshop
    Beginner

    Mob Programming is based on the simple concept that five brains are smarter than one, but how do you harness those brains to focus on a single goal?  In this fun and interactive session we explore the roles and concepts of Mob Programming using LEGO® Serious Play®.

    Attendees will be part of Mob teams that take a product request from a customer and, using the Mob roles of the Driver, the Navigator, and the Team, will create their product in LEGO®. Utilizing a Test Drive Development (TDD) framework, each Mob team tests, builds, tests, and delivers a finished product using a basic set of requirements.  Discover what it’s like to be a Mob team member as you cycle through the various roles and phases in a fun, non-technical setting; you don’t even need previous LEGO® experience, after all that is what the Mob is there for!

  • Liked Christina Marin
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Christina Marin - Theatre of the Oppressed

    180 mins
    Workshop
    Beginner

    This hands-on workshop will introduce participants to some of the games and techniques from the arsenal of the Theatre of the Oppressed. These games have been used internationally to address diverse issues from oppression, workers rights, leadership, and collaboration. No theatre experience is needed. Attendees should come prepared to move around… A LOT! This is a very physical workshop, although every effort will be made to accommodate observers who may have any physical challenges, whether temporary or permanent. It is our every intention to create an inclusive environment. Participants and observers will all receive an outline of the games with detailed instructions, as well as a list of resources so they can learn more about this applied theatre form.

  • Liked Christophe THIBAUT
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Christophe THIBAUT / Christophe THIBAUT / Frederic Merizen - The Mob Programming Game or How a Group of Humans Escaped From Doom With The Help of A Simple Robot

    90 mins
    Workshop
    Intermediate

    Your group of brave space pioneers is caught in a disruption of spacetime. You need to get a message out there that you need help, and pronto. But will you get your ridiculously primitive robot to draw the SOS in time?

    In this workshop, you will learn something about programming as a group. Hopefully you will also have a good time!