The Agile Qtopia - A Critique of Agile in the Wild

Do people cry in heaven? Agile is projected as a utopian view of the IT world. Then why are you still crying? Behind the facade of some magical success with Agile, most of the companies and teams are still struggling to get the software right (and/or build the right software, whatever English restructuring has an official term coined for it). People - who are at the center of Agile philosophy - are unhappy. This does not look like a utopia. Calling it a dystopia would be an extreme too. It is a Qtopia (to answer an Indian smirk, yes! you can also read it as ***topia).

Let's have an honest look at what Agile is meant to be and what most organizations make of it in the light of Agile manifesto.


Outline/Structure of the Case Study

The presentation would have the following tentative structure:

  • Importance of honest critique
  • A non-IT analogy to drive the point home
  • A look at Agile Manifesto and its practical implications
  • More constraints from an Indian context
  • The final message

Learning Outcome

There are types of knowledge namely: factual, conceptual, procedural and meta-cognition.

This presentation appeals to the last one in the context of Agile. It makes one question about the way s/he thinks about Agile and why some things might not work in one's context.

This in my opinion is the most difficult form of learning. Can a single presentation bring such a change? I don't expect this to happen for all attendees, however I hope to touch atleast a few minds.

Target Audience

Any one with an open mind

Prerequisites for Attendees

There are not pre-requisites. This is a philosophical talk.

schedule Submitted 1 year ago

Public Feedback

    • Dave Snowden

      Dave Snowden - Is Mindset yet another agile buzzword?

      45 Mins

      While it is true to say that people’s attitudes and beliefs are key to implementing an agile project, or Agile in itself, much of the use of the term ‘mindset’ implies a mental model that can be defined and engineered. In this presentation, we will look at how we can measure attitudes within an organization and use multiple small actions to trigger the rapid evolution of organizational culture, so that it can sustain agile developments. Mindset and the alignment-based ideas of some on the Agile movement too often imply creating homogeneous beliefs and values that will lead to full alignment. In practice, this damages resilience and can be dangerous. This presentation will introduce the idea of coherence instead of alignment - the celebration of cognitive and behavioral differences that can align if needed to support the delivery of sustainable solutions.

    • Pragyan Misra

      Pragyan Misra - Artfully Empathize - Enable Design Thinking using Neuro-Linguistic Programming(NLP) Techniques

      Pragyan Misra
      Pragyan Misra
      Agile Coach
      schedule 1 year ago
      Sold Out!
      90 Mins

      The Agile Manifesto establishes a set of four values that are people-centered and results driven. As we all know, while there is value in the items to the right, we value the items on the left more. In my workshop, I will focus how the agile value "individuals and interactions over processes and tools" is leveraged during the design thinking using neuro-linguistic programming techniques.

      When we are in the journey of transformation, we want to be an agile organization. To be an agile organization, while we focus on value delivery, the need to empathize with our internal and external customers is important, so that we understand their requirement and bring in value to them. This can be done by the way we interact with empathy while we work on the user requirement and designing their journey. So let us explore how to "Artfully Empathize"

      How do we understand what our customers/stakeholders need from us?

      One of the most important customer-centric approach is to understand their need by asking the right questions, listening and empathizing.

      How do we develop the art of asking the right questions with empathy?

      HCD - The best way to innovate for someone is to understand them. By understanding a person’s thoughts, motivations, emotions, barriers, etc., you can identify their needs, and design to meet those needs. Human Centered Design is a known framework that provides solutions to problems involving a human perspective. Now the uniqueness of the workshop will include NLP techniques that will help empathize effectively.

      NLP – Using NLP, we will learn about our modalities and meta-models, which is a language pattern that encourages the listener to move to higher levels of thinking and help them explore the unknowns. It will empower us to explore our potential to ask the right questions. We will leverage this technique in our workshop to focus on the Empathy and Design phase of the HCD.

      Welcome to the exploration journey of being artfully empathetic!