Stakeholder Engagement in the Process of Research on Child Sex Trafficking in West Africa

Whereas stakeholder engagement in policy implementation and service provisions to victims of human trafficking is substantially documented in the literature, there are almost no studies on stakeholder engagement in the process of research on this global problem. Yet, input from stakeholders is critical for most studies about human trafficking. Based on an international research study on child prostitution conducted in the West African region, the present paper examines the characteristics of stakeholders and the key ways they were engaged in the research process, from the preparatory stage to the translational stage. A total of 133 stakeholders in 13 major categories were involved in the research process. The paper shows how the involvement of various stakeholders in the development of the study helped improve the outcomes of the research, and most important, helped increase the likelihood of acceptance and dissemination of the findings. The paper also describes examples of implementation of the study findings by stakeholders and discusses implications for future research.


Outline/Structure of the Original Research


Literature Review

1. Stakeholder Engagement in Research
2. Categories of Stakeholder Engaged in Research
3. Importance of Engaging Stakeholders in Research Process
4. Stakeholder Engagement in the Process of Research on Human Trafficking


1. Theoretical Framework
2. Study Setting
3. Stakeholder Characteristics


1. Preparatory Stage of the Research
2. Execution Stage of the Research
3. Translational Stage of the Research



Learning Outcome

  • Learn about strategies to conduct research with hard-to-reach population, especially victims of human trafficking in an international setting;
  • Lean about successful strategies to engage stakeholders (international, governmental, non-governmental, community, policymakers, service providers, educators, etc.) to actively participate in the process of research on human trafficking; and
  • Learn about key roles stakeholders can play in the problem formulation, research design, data collection, and dissemination of study findings, etc.

Target Audience

Researchers and professionals working with hard-to-reach populations, and people interested in research and outreach with human trafficking cases.

schedule Submitted 2 years ago

Public Feedback

comment Suggest improvements to the Speaker
  • SAFE Coalition for Human Rights (SAFECHR)
    reply Reply

    I like these aspects of the submission, and they should be retained:

    • ...relevant topic and speaker is known to the SAFE Conference due to previous presentation

    I think the submission could be improved by:

    • ...

  • Liked SAFE Coalition for Human Rights (SAFECHR)

    SAFE Coalition for Human Rights (SAFECHR) - ACES: Vulnerabilities to Human Trafficking

    75 Mins

    Dr. Vincent Filetti is the co-developer of the ACEs which is highlighted in the current presentation. This is a rare event, a seminal workshop that Dr. Filetti is graciously providing to participants of SAFE 2018. The talk is unique in its addressing human trafficking and how ACEs impacts the vulnerability of youth and adults to human trafficking. His speaking engagements are very limited at this time, and we are honored to have him give us his time.

  • Liked Ezemba Stanley

    Ezemba Stanley - Transnational Trafficking: What are the factors that have supported the transnational trafficking of minors and adults in labor and sex trafficking? What are the current and best practices available to combat it?

    15 Mins

    To deal with any issue we need knowledge, information and believe. for us to bring information to the highest level where it will have maximum effect we must involve music. I believe in the power of music as a tool to drive imformation. when we speak or talk the ear listens but most times lacks the will to diseminate to the emotions for the benefit of the system but when music speak emotion listens and imformation content is well digested for maximum effect. We must bring in creative songs to help us in spreading information when it comes to stop trafficking, child labour and other social vices

  • Liked Elizabeth Ziemba

    Elizabeth Ziemba - Human Trafficking and the LGBTQ+ Youth Population: A Socioecological perspective on Risk, Identification, Prevention, and Making a Difference

    Elizabeth Ziemba
    Elizabeth Ziemba
    Carter Brown
    schedule 1 year ago
    Sold Out!
    45 Mins
    Original Research

    Presenters: Joy Kelleher, LCSW and Elizabeth Ziemba

    Time: minimum 45 minutes; maximum 90 minutes

    The issues surrounding the unique needs and challenges of the LGBTQ+ community are being viewed from a lens of safety and human rights. However, there is still a dearth in research that addresses multifaceted risk factors in the LGBTQ+ community in regards to the vulnerability of these youth. Human trafficking continues its insidious evolution within this group of society. According to the Polaris Project website, there have been nearly 21 million victims of human trafficking globally, with more than 26% of those victims being children (Polaris, 2018). The LGBTQ+ youth population are more vulnerable to human trafficking. This group makes up a disproportionate 40% of the homeless youth (this is in comparison to just 7% of the general population identifying as LGBTQ+) and they are 3-7 times more likely to engage in “survival sex” (Polaris, 2018).

    Are you aware?

    LGBTQ+ youth are at more risk due to the higher incidents of homelessness, family isolation, violence, discrimination, and economic hardships leaving them open to exploitation by traffickers who hone in on the absence of positive connections and security. Although LGBTQ+ organizations advocate for victims of trafficking, but often these youth do not have access to prevention measures or services because of the fear of societal and systemic discrimination (Xian, Chock, Dwiggins, 2017). These children are often victim to multi-layered vulnerabilities unique to their population: not meeting social norms; lack of safe environments to express their identity and lack of safety in home, educational, health care, and spiritual systems; disproportionate homelessness, and the absence of positive interpersonal relationships with others outside their social group.

    Xian, Chock, and Dwiggins (2017) use the socioecological model to identify the need for specific advocacy, outreach, and survivor programs for LGBTQ+ trafficked youth; legal policies that protect from discrimination; and funding for programs that provide safe care. This presentation will provide an overview of existing research on the topic of risk. In addition, we will explore avenues of identification, prevention, rescue, and treatment. The context of this discussion will be viewed through the self-determination theory of sense of belonging as belonging is an essential facet of self-determination; we will highlight this theory as a means of addressing and impacting this complex issue.

  • 90 Mins
    Original Research

    Serious games (SGs) provide a space of cognitive and emotional engagement where participants experience, interact, and enact social worlds that might not otherwise be possible; therefore, allowing a psychosocial meaning-making process to unfold. Moreover, SGs move beyond embedded prosocial messages and mere entertainment value and serve as facilitators of deeper and more personalized processes through creating new complex environments of embodied experiences. The process of engaging in experiential learning, actively constructing educational outcomes (e.g., constructivism), on-the-spot problem solving, and other features, make serious games qualitatively different than traditional approaches.

    This presentation seeks to articulate the process by which a research and design team employed a transdisciplinary, participatory approach to develop a game-based prevention tool aimed at tackling commercial sexual exploitation of children (CSEC). Given the complexity of CSEC, this project moves away from traditional methodologies, and presents an interactive, experientially-based approach to reducing the stigmatization of child victims and increasing empathic feelings on behalf of community members. Months of formative research, game development, and findings of in-depth analysis will be shared.

    Through engaging in a simulated, role-playing safe space participants gain a deeper understanding of the risk factors and reporting mechanisms of CSEC. By creating a space where participants can think ‘as someone else,’ this CSEC prevention game (Play if Safe) allows for both solution-based dialogue to emerge and new avenues for collaboration to be explored for prevention, service provision, and data reporting of CSEC.

    Beyond learning about Play if Safe, participants will have an opportunity to work alongside others in a mini game development sessions centered on their own area of interest within the larger umbrella of CSEC.

  • Liked Linda Thomas

    Linda Thomas / Jeanne Allert - Assumptions vs. Realities in Long-Term Survivor Care

    90 Mins
    Case Study

    The Samaritan Women has been providing comprehensive, long-term residential care for female victims of domestic sex trafficking and childhood sexual abuse for 10 years. This session presents a composite of the extensive data they have accumulated from intake, clinical and psychological assessments, case management, service providers, and client progress notes. The session will focus on how that data has challenged their assumptions about survivor needs and informed program architecturew and services.

  • Liked Youngbee Dale

    Youngbee Dale - Beyond Massage Parlors: Exposing the Korean Sex Market in the U.S.

    45 Mins
    Original Research

    This presentation exposes the Korean sex market beyond massage parlors. In the past, the U.S. anti-trafficking efforts have heavily focused on combating massage parlors to fight Korean sex trafficking in the U.S. The presentation will illuminate changing trafficking techniques, victim characteristics, and new brothel models used by traffickers in response to changing cultural and policy trends taking place in the U.S. and South Korea. It will also present current challenges faced by the law enforcement and NGOs to fight Korean sex trafficking nationwide. Lastly, it offers recommendations to fight the Korean sex market in the U.S. more effectively.

  • Liked Jessica Chen

    Jessica Chen - A Study of Cross-Border Trafficking from Nepal to India

    30 Mins
    Original Research

    At the border between Nepal and India, citizens from the two countries are free to cross without being required to show identification. The porousness of the border has led to the flourishing of human trafficking from Nepal into India, as traffickers are able to transport individuals across the border unimpeded. In response, NGOs began setting up unofficial checkpoints along the border to intercept women and girls whom they believed were being trafficked. NGO staff watch for suspicious signs among travelers and question those they deem to be possible victims.

    Love Justice International is an NGO that currently operates 20 border-monitoring stations in Nepal, and this presentation offers an analysis of over five years of data collected by THN about trafficking activity from Nepal across its border with India. THN began its border-monitoring work in 2006 and has collected extensive data from thousands of intercepts, including demographics of the trafficking victims (such as age, gender, education, economic status, and employment background), motives for going abroad, recruitment methods, promises offered, relationships to traffickers, trafficking routes, and destinations. This presentation will identify trends and compare them with the prevailing understanding of human trafficking trends in Nepal. THN also facilitates the filing of legal cases against traffickers, and this presentation will do a case study of approximately 60 convictions to analyze: 1) what substantive and procedural factors may lead to a successful conviction for trafficking, a conviction for a lesser offense, or an acquittal; 2) what proportion of intercepts lead to legal action; and 3) the factors relevant to whether legal action is taken.

  • Liked Stefania Agliano

    Stefania Agliano - Saving Our Boys to Save Our Girls

    90 Mins

    Many of the discussions, prevention/intervention programming, as well as front line assessments are designed to target either the victim (survivor) of sex trafficking or the buyer by addressing demand through legal interventions or educational programming. The missing component in the fight to eradicate trafficking is a lack of dialogue on services for the potential trafficker. As founders of I AM: The Empowerment Project we were called to action when we began to take a closer look at how pimps and traffickers were portrayed in the media, many times by the anti-trafficking community itself. We observed how young men who were gang involved, in juvenile detention facilities, involved in criminal activity and often difficult to engage were presented, discussed and treated. All too often these young men were discarded and seen as having little worth as their crimes increased, as well as their age, and sadly these were frequently our most vulnerable youth who are marginalized due their race, socioeconomic status and lack of opportunities designed for success. It was clear that many of these young men were lost on the cradle to prison pipeline and more than likely going to enter the adult criminal system further sinking them into a life of crime and depravity. So we dared to create an avenue of prevention and intervention focused on our young men who participate in this heinous crime as the market facilitator engaging in highly abusive behaviors; I AM: Building A Healthy Male Identity. While females can be and are traffickers, this workshop is specifically focused on male perpetrators. Workshop participants will be given an overview on the importance of working with young men and boys and insights into the struggle of those who become involved in the crime of trafficking may face, including but not limited to, the mass marketing of hyper-masculinity, socioeconomic inequalities and institutionalized oppression. We firmly believe that by helping our young men and boys to build a healthier sense of self we can potentially save our young women and girls from exploitation, trafficking and other forms of violence. This provides a unique prevention strategy that can only enhance efforts.

    This workshop provides a closer look at the role that racial disparities and social inequities play in the creation of the trafficker which can only serve to enhance law enforcement response and social service intervention. By discussing the trafficker as someone needing intervention and prevention services in addition to victims and buyers we position ourselves on the national level to make systemic changes for young men to enhance their well-being while potentially eliminating the market facilitator.

  • Liked Amy E Rouleau

    Amy E Rouleau - Sex Trafficking and Early Childhood Sexual Abuse; One Survivor’s Story and Restoration

    60 Mins

    This engaging journey will provide a greater understanding of how the foster care system, the human brain, and human trafficking are all connected. Amy’s personal testimony will leave you inspired and hopeful for a future without human trafficking.

    When a child experiences trauma, the developing brain has the capacity to shut down certain areas, to self-protect. As Amy explains the data and her own experience with abuse, severe disassociation, substance abuse, and cognitive issues, deeper systemic issues will unfold. While no child, or adult, is completely immune from the evils of human trafficking, those who have already experienced severe trauma are more likely to fall victim. Children in foster care, runaways, throwaways, and homeless are at a much greater risk of being trafficked than the typical child in America. Preventing human trafficking has proven to be a difficult endeavor, but do not lose hope. Through holistic approaches in mental health, early education, law enforcement, and foster care, intervention and restoration is possible.

  • Liked Charles Hounmenou

    Charles Hounmenou - proposal submission - cancelled

  • Liked Linda Thomas

    Linda Thomas - Continuum of Care Model for Survivors of Domestic Sex Trafficking

    60 Mins

    Since 2007 The Samaritan Women has been building and refining its unique Continuum of Care Model for survivors of domestic sex trafficking. Under the direction of Jeanne Allert, this organization has emerged as one of the national leaders in long-term, restorative care. The Samaritan Women operates multiple locations in Maryland serving female victims from 19 different states and remains the only residential program for adult survivors in the state.

    This session takes attendees through TSW's process of creating a human services model where no prior model existed and for a population against which very little is known. Jeanne will share the clinical expertise and approaches to care that TSW has incorporated into its model and where TSW had to be truly innovative.