Practice Does not Make Perfect: Why Agile Transformations Fail

These days, almost every organization is showing interest in Agile. We seem to have all the ingredients for effective transformations: well-known practices, detailed processes, ever-improving tools, extensive literature, myriad certifications, and many consultants. How is it, then, that so few organizations are truly agile?

Gil Broza, author of “The Agile Mindset” and “The Human Side of Agile”, thinks that one particular ingredient has been overlooked in the mad rush to adopt Agile. In this session, he leads us on an exploration of that ingredient and its place in an Agile transformation.

 
6 favorite thumb_down thumb_up 0 comments visibility_off  Remove from Watchlist visibility  Add to Watchlist
 

Outline/structure of the Session

I share a conceptual model (the Logical Levels) and the attendees do a quick exercise to understand it better (individual exercise + comparing notes with their neighbour). Then we expand the model in the context of work and instantiate it with Agile values and principles. In a second exercise, we use the model to understand how popular Agile practices came to be. The high point of this talk follows when we use the model to understand how those practices get watered down and misguided when dropped, plug-and-play style, into an environment that still thinks along non-Agile lines. (In other words, we debunk Shu-Ha-Ri). We follow with a discussion of key elements for changing how people and organizations operate.

I've given this talk in various formats: 20, 45, and 60 minutes. The description above is for the 40 minute version. If you'd like me to do 60 minutes, I will introduce one more exercise, and there will be more interaction.

Learning Outcome

Gain clarity on necessary and oft-ignored elements of Agile transformations.

Target Audience

managers, leaders, executives, ScrumMasters, project managers

schedule Submitted 2 months ago

Comments Subscribe to Comments

comment Comment on this Proposal

  • 40 mins
    Talk
    Intermediate

    Although self-organizing teams are crucial to carrying out a successful Agile transformation, organizations that implement Agile at scale invariably realize that the introduction of such teams forces the organization to re-engineer numerous aspects of its operating philosophy. In particular, various management layers are often removed. The individuals in these layers are routinely re-purposed or laid off.

    This talk highlights the approaches I used as an Agilist in various organizations to help people in different roles on their journey of transitioning into the world of Agile. Specifically, the talk will focus on 5 key roles: Project Managers, Product Managers, BA Managers, Development Managers, and QA Managers. It will provide insight into how managers can effectively transition to some of the new Agile roles, or redefine their existing role to effectively fit in an Agile world.

    The emphasis in this talk is on pragmatic strategies for managers that are struggling to find their place in this new Agile world. Armed with these strategies, participants will be able to effectively adapt to the Agile transformation, as well as discover potential new career paths for themselves and for the individuals reporting to them.

  • Liked Chris Murman
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Chris Murman - Brainwriting: The Team Hack To Generating Better Ideas

    Chris Murman
    Chris Murman
    Sr. Agile Consultant
    Solutions IQ
    schedule 1 month ago
    Sold Out!
    90 mins
    Workshop
    Beginner

    Brainstorming has long been held as the best way to get ideas from teams for decades, but what if we are wrong? Can we take the successful aspects of collaboration and create a better environment for quality concepts? Come learn about brainwriting and get more from your team today!

    If you work in an office, you have probably participated in a brainstorming session or two (or 12). Invented in the 1940s by an advertising executive, the purpose was to solicit many ideas in a short period of time. By putting a collective of creative people in the same room, better concepts should come. Sounds very agile. 

    However, science has shown several times that brainstorming not the best way to generate ideas. It’s cumbersome due to all of the interdependent activities happening at once. When spending time generating ideas as a group, you often spend more time thinking of others ideas than your own. 

    Fortunately, a relatively unknown technique is starting to gain popularity called brainwriting. Incorporating it into your team events can produce more diverse ideas and provide a friendlier environment for collaboration. In this session, we will workshop them and leave the audience with all of the tools to bring the technique back to their offices.

     

    What Makes It Compelling:

    I was skeptical when I first read an article on the technique, mainly because I had always believed brainstorming produced quality ideas. As a “stickies and sharpies” type of coach, I’d seen so many teams collectively throw out ideas during planning and retrospective sessions. But in the ensuing weeks, I started seeing where the article was on point in terms of producing quality ideas.

    After contrasting the ideas generated after using brainwriting for a few weeks, my mind was changed forever. Even better was the events themselves didn’t seem that different to teams. 

  • Liked Scott Ambler
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Scott Ambler - The Executive’s Guide to Disciplined Agile: Business Agility for Established Enterprises

    60 mins
    Talk
    Intermediate

    An agile enterprise increases value through effective execution and delivery in a timely and reactive manner. Such organizations do this by streamlining the flow of information, ideas, decision making, and work throughout the overall business process all the while improving the quality of the process and business outcomes.   This talk describes, step-by-step, how to evolve from today’s vision of agile software development to a truly disciplined agile enterprise. It briefly examines the state of mainstream agile software development and argues for the need for a more disciplined approach to agile delivery that provides a solid foundation from which to scale. We then explore what it means to scale disciplined agile strategies tactically at the project/product level. We then work through what it means to strategically scale across your IT organization as a whole and discover what a Disciplined DevOps strategy looks like in practice. Your Disciplined Agile IT strategy, along with a lean business strategy, are key enablers of a full-fledged disciplined agile enterprise. The talk ends with advice for how to make this challenging organizational transition.

  • Liked Fawzy Manaa
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Fawzy Manaa - How to Lose Dev and Alienate Ops

    Fawzy Manaa
    Fawzy Manaa
    Senior Consultant
    Deloitte
    schedule 1 week ago
    Sold Out!
    40 mins
    Talk
    Beginner

    As many organizations have adopted agile development and are starting to undertake a DevOps transformation to complete the lifecycle, it is not always easy to keep traditionally alienated back office practitioners engaged. In fact, many organizations go about engaging developers, testers, operators, ... in a way that does not align with the spirit of DevOps. Many enterprise DevOps transformations fail because of this very reason, this session will inform the audience of what it takes to create a strong and sustainable movement within an IT organization in today's world where people who perform different functions that are seemingly at odds can come together in the spirit of improving how work is done and delivered.

    The speaker will approach the topic from an anti-patterns perspective, highlighting the symptoms of transformation failure from structural, procedural, and strategic angles and discussing alternative approaches to enable DevOps transformation success.

  • Liked Steve Zhang
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Steve Zhang - The Joy Of Functional Programming

    60 mins
    Talk
    Intermediate

    The popularity of Functional Programming is booming! Are you still wondering what all of the fuss is about? Come to this session and find out! This is an introduction to the power of functional programming. It covers functional programming's basic concepts, and shows you how functional programming will make software simple, elegant, easy to test, and lead to cleaner code. I will share my experiences learning, so you can avoid some of the pitfalls. So if you enjoy coding, love clean code, then you should start learning Functional Programming right now.

  • Liked Mishkin Berteig
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Mishkin Berteig - JIRA is the Worst Possible Choice

    90 mins
    Workshop
    Intermediate

    A rant, with evidence, on why electronic tools in general, and JIRA in particular, are anti-Agile. Participants will use the Agile Manifesto to evaluate the electronic tools they are currently familiar with. JIRA is used as a case study.

    NOTE: Scrum asks us to have courage. The Agile Manifesto asks us to value individuals and interactions over processes and tools. I hope the organizing committee will consider this proposal despite the risk that it might offend some tool vendors. If we can't speak freely about our experiences with tools, we will fail as a community.

  • Liked Laurelle
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Laurelle - Moving Forward In Circles: Lessons Learned In Agile Transformation

    Laurelle
    Laurelle
    Co-founder
    Vocalmeet
    schedule 1 month ago
    Sold Out!
    40 mins
    Talk
    Intermediate

    Agile has gone mainstream and individuals everywhere are adopting Agile techniques and practices. In the process, they are interpreting what Agile means individually and what Agile means at an organizational level. 

    People are interpreting Agile techniques and practices in ways that at times create organizational chaos, conflict and lead to dramatic failure.

    Using humor, visual aids and a highly active approach, this session explores some real world case studies of how some organizations have interpreted and adopted agile. It explores pitfalls to avoid and best practices.

    The session provides a blueprint for success with Agile transformation.

  • Liked Dave Dame
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Dave Dame - Design Thinking for Organizational Change

    40 mins
    Talk
    Beginner

    We all know how people use design thinking to create better products and deliver delightful experiences to our users. However, design thinking can be an excellent tool to use for organizational change. In the case of organizational change, our product is the change that we are trying to drive, and our customers are those people who are impacted (internally and externally) and have to live with that change. In the same way that design thinking puts the user front-and-centre for products, it can be used to put people in the organization front-and-centre. In this talk we will discuss how design thinking works and, as a case study, how we have applied it at Scotiabank to help drive adoption of the Bank’s NPS customer insights into building solutions that serve our customers. In that program, previous internal processes were ineffective in pushing relevant data to delivery teams at the right time. Using a Lean or Agile approach would have provided some benefit, but taking a design thinking approach uncovered an array of useful insights to make the whole process more purposeful. Learn from this example to explore how you might incorporate design thinking to drive greater effectiveness and relevance for your team’s body of work.

  • Liked James Gifford
    keyboard_arrow_down

    James Gifford - 5 Metrics to Create Safety and High Performing Teams

    60 mins
    Talk
    Intermediate

    Description:

    I see that a lot of organizations use metrics in inappropriate ways to measure teams. At the heart of these metrics, nine times out of ten, are velocity and story points. These metrics lead to a lot of mistrust, fear, and bad technical practices. This talk will focus on shifting the focus to diagnostic metrics.

     Before shifting focus to diagnostic metrics, we need to understand what inappropriate metrics are. When questioning teams about why their velocity was lower from one sprint to another, teams are more likely to inflate their estimates to avoid questions in the future. This is one of my scenarios. We will explore this case and my other top-ten based on the 165 teams I have interacted with. Focusing on one metric does not provide a balanced view of the team.

    For balance, I promote five metrics. The combination of metrics balances each other. These five metrics are lead time, quality, happiness, agile maturity, and business value. Focusing on these five metric areas can be used as a diagnostic tool to help teams grow and support coaching. During the session, we will use my Excel-based tool and visual model to simulate this balance.

    When you push shorter lead times (how fast) on a team with a lower agile maturity, the first thing to change is quality, followed by happiness and then the delivery of value. Conversely, if a team focuses on TDD, the first thing to change is quality, followed by agile maturity, reduction in lead time, and increased delivery of value.  

    Teaching teams to harness data in a positive way will help them to flourish.

  • Shawn Button
    Shawn Button
    Agile Coach
    Leanintuit
    schedule 1 week ago
    Sold Out!
    60 mins
    Talk
    Beginner

    We are about launch our latest feature to the eager public, when suddenly we get the call all developers dread: The Site is down! Our business is pressuring us to quickly come back up, but we can’t even find the problem! We pick up the red phone and call Karen, "The Site Whisperer." She calmly spends five minutes typing, and announces that she found the problem, and everything is back to normal. Where would we be without Karen? How can we get these skills on the rest of the team, so anyone can work the magic she does?

    It turns out that troubleshooting is a learnable skill. Join Shawn as he explores the Science of Troubleshooting. This workshop will examine what is happening during effective problem solving. It will examine types of scientific reasoning, and explore how we are using them to solve problems, sometimes without even realizing what we are doing! Participants will see how, by using scientific reasoning and experiments to build and test hypotheses, they can greatly increase the effectiveness of their troubleshooting and debugging. By making the process explicit even consummate problem solvers can improve how they approach and solve problems. Using the awareness gained attendees can guide others to improve their problem-solving skills.

  • Liked Alistair McKinnell
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Alistair McKinnell - Don't Settle for Poor Names

    60 mins
    Talk
    Advanced

    I get frustrated with code that is sprinkled with poorly named classes, methods, and variables.

    Whenever I work on a team or coach a team, I put a lot of energy into choosing good names and sensitizing my teammates to the power of naming.

    I've noticed that developers spend most of their days reading code rather than writing code. I suspect you've noticed too. Creating understandable code is a high leverage activity for any team. And naming is where I start.

    The core of the session is an example that illustrates the process and power of choosing good names. The example comes from a recent project. There will be code.

    I will connect the example to specific techniques and patterns for choosing good names and share resources that you can use right away.

    My goal for this session is to sensitize you to the power of naming.

  • Liked Alexandra Ursea
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Alexandra Ursea - SCARF Model - How to collaborate with and influence others and succeed

    Alexandra Ursea
    Alexandra Ursea
    Independent Consultant
    N/A
    schedule 3 weeks ago
    Sold Out!
    60 mins
    Talk
    Advanced

    Have you ever been in a position in which you were actively engaged in a massive organizational transformation or personal one? Have you struggled with it? Have you tried different leadership styles or approaches but you were still discontent with the results?

    Perhaps the greatest challenge facing leaders in organizations is to create the kind of atmosphere in which people feel treated fairly, promote autonomy and creativity, foster certainty whenever possible, draw people together to solve problems and find ways to raise the perceived status of everyone.

    If you are a leader, every action you take and every decision you make either support or undermines your objective. Every word or glance is loaded with social meaning. Your gestures and sentences are noticed, interpreted and magnified for meanings you may never have intended.

    This is why leading is so difficult!

    Humans cannot think creatively, work well with others or make informed decisions when their threat responses are on high alert. Leaders who understand this and act accordingly could make a very positive impact in their organizations.

    David Rock,CEO of Results Coaching Intl and co-founder of the NeuroLeadership Institute developed a model known as the SCARF model (Status, Certainty, Autonomy, Relatedness, Fairness) to describe the social concerns that drive human behaviour and which leaders could benefit from to smooth organizational transformation.

    The SCARF model provides a means of bringing conscious awareness to people’s core concerns and shows how to attune your actions to better effect.

    This session will address the foundations of the SCARF model, the five domains of human social experience: Status, Certainty, Autonomy, Relatedness, Fairness as well as the broader application of this model.

  • Liked Paul J. Heidema
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Paul J. Heidema - Vital Behaviours of Successful Scrum Masters and How to Make Them Stick

    90 mins
    Workshop
    Intermediate

    Agile failure is most felt by Scrum Masters. Why do so many fail to properly support their teams? Why do so many fail to inspire meaningful change in the level of leadership? Why do so many fail to guide transformation in their organisations?

    In this workshop, we will harness the knowledge and experience of the participants!

    Influencer Book

    Why?
    Because everyone can contribute to the learning of the entire group. It will dynamic, full or energy, and joyful - woohoo!

    Who can benefit the most from the session and the power of harnessing the group?

    • Scrum Masters that are struggling to do this role well
    • Leaders that are not seeing the results needed for an effective Scrum team through a weak/unskilled Scrum Master
    • Agile coaches that are coaching Scrum Masters without meaningful or consistent results
    • Project managers trying to make the transition to becoming a successful Scrum Master

    This workshop will use concepts and the model from the book "Influencer"

    Prepare to work together to co-discover the Scrum Master vital behaviours!

    Many people are taking on the mantle of Scrum Masters across agile teams around the world. Unfortunately, many of them have come from more traditional work structures that don't develop effective Scrum Masters. There is a misconception about the purpose of a Scrum Master. Often the Scrum Master becomes the facilitator or the project manager. This has to stop. Effective leaders, agile coaches, and Scrum Masters take advantage of vital behaviours in supporting scrum masters or by building mastery within these behaviours.

    Influencer - the model

    During this workshop, participants will go through a series of exercises to identify the purpose of a Scrum Master, how we can measure success, identify potential vital behaviours, learn from others to determine the vital behaviours, and then create a sound influence strategy to enable effective Scrum Masters and the work that they do. This workshop will use concepts and the model from the book "Influencer" (by Joseph Grenny et all) which details the three (3) keys to a successful change initiative and uses the six (6) sources of influence.

    Prepare to work together to co-discover the Scrum Master vital behaviours!

  • 40 mins
    Talk
    Beginner

    Many organizations flatten management structure when they transform to agile. It soon becomes obvious that important activities done by managers are still needed.  A community can fill these gaps. They can provide morale, governance, learning, and mentorship, recruiting and hiring, mutual support, coordination, sharing, innovation and more!

    Unfortunately few companies manage to create a strong community. Even fewer empower that community to fill these gaps. This means they are missing the ultimate benefit of community: a strong, empowered community can transform the organization itself!

    Join Shahin and Shawn in this interactive session to explore communities in organizations. Examine the benefits of building great communities. Learn how to spark the community, and how to support it as it evolves. Hear stories of communities empowered to improve the organization. Learn how to make a community into a driver of positive change.

  • Liked Shuman Ip
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Shuman Ip - Richer in my wallet, poorer in our wallet?

    Shuman Ip
    Shuman Ip
    Scrum Master
    LoyaltyOne
    schedule 1 month ago
    Sold Out!
    60 mins
    Talk
    Intermediate

    Does your company do performance review?

    Since the goal of all for-profit companies is to make profit, how effect is performance review in actually contributing to your business goal?

    In this session, we will go through some activities to explore the hidden side of performance appraisal process, along with some story-telling and discussions on our perspectives.

    Last but not least, there will be some suggestions on things that we can do in place of the traditional performance review.

    If you want to unmask the mystery behind performance review
    If the current performance appraisal process is one of your pain points, or
    If you have experience and stories to share with us regarding performance evaluation, then come to this session and let's have a conversation

  • Liked Ardita Karaj
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Ardita Karaj - Getting Freddie Mercury and Spice Girls together on stage

    Ardita Karaj
    Ardita Karaj
    Enterprise Agile Coach
    Tango
    schedule 1 month ago
    Sold Out!
    40 mins
    Talk
    Intermediate

    Ever been in a situation when the Product Manager comes and asks for “a couple of small changes that are high priority” and the team says “They’re kind of big. Which one do you want first? Really, really!”.  “I want them all! As soon as possible.”.

    There are many directions one can go from here. One can work harder or work smarter. While you probably know ways to work harder, but let’s explore ways to work smarter.

    In this talk Ardita will share techniques that she has used which produce good results. She will talk about Product management, technical backbone, collaboration and how all to get Product managers and teams “singing” together in harmony and with focus.

  • Liked Dave Dame
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Dave Dame - Coaching Leadership in an Agile Transformation

    40 mins
    Talk
    Intermediate

    How do you coach leaders in an agile transformation? How does coaching this group differ from coaching on an agile team? How do you coach Leadership as their peer? Agile is always thought of as being ‘down in the delivery layer’ of organizations. But, for us to be truly successful in embracing agility, we need to be more inclusive of all decision makers in the organization. That starts at the top. There are lot of cultural elements and tools that need to be changed across the organization. This requires dedicated change agents to be positioned within the environment of senior leaders to help them embrace agility in their everyday and strategic decision making. Most people want to do the right thing – it’s all about coaching so that, in the moments where our intentions and our decisions are tested by the status quo, we can help our leaders evaluate their choices. This means being a constant influencer, mirror and educator. And, it means sometimes you have to let things go. Successfully coaching leaders through agile transformation requires very purposeful influencing. In this session, we will discuss how to help bring senior leaders along an agile change journey as well as the primary challenges you are likely to encounter along the way and proven mechanisms to help you push through.

  • Liked Dave Dame
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Dave Dame - Design thinking and Agile: Infinitely more powerful together

    40 mins
    Talk
    Beginner

    When Agile first came on the scene it was premised around putting the customer first. But, over the years its focus has evolved and the general perception of Agile today is that it’s mostly a tool for delivering software. Agile’s original focus was mainly on developers and testers, but it never really contemplated design thinking as a discipline. Design thinking, which has been around for decades but is only recently having its ‘moment in the sun’, compliments agile beautifully in that it focuses on trying to solve the right problems for the right people. Design thinking allows us to iterate and test assumptions before too much coding and production-readiness is done, which helps ensure the team is investing in the right things at every stage. It really provides a focus on innovating rather than simply burning down a backlog. In this talk we will discuss different ways to incorporate design thinking into the agile process. You will learn how to yield benefits from bringing these two practices together – most importantly how to best serve the users of the product or service you are delivering. At Scotiabank, we’ve been using these fantastic tools in combination for over a year. It is a journey, and although we haven’t completely solved everything yet, there are a lot of lessons we have learned that can be applied elsewhere.

  • Liked Louis Morisset
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Louis Morisset - What is the impact of your organization's culture on your agile transformation

    Louis Morisset
    Louis Morisset
    Agile Coach
    Agile Partnership
    schedule 1 month ago
    Sold Out!
    60 mins
    Panel
    Intermediate

    More and more companies are, right or wrong reasons, deciding to do agile transformations.  In this talk, we question ourselves on what it takes to start an agile transformation in big corporation. We will introduce the maturity model of Mickael Spayd and Lyssa Adkins and reflect on the importance of understanding the maturity level of our company before starting an agile transformation. We will also explore, based on each maturity levels, what are the realistic expectations of an agile transformation and where people should focus on to help more the initiative forward. Finally we will also look at the individuals level of maturity and see how this impacts their companies agile transformation as well as the people themselves. 

  • Liked Jess Long
    keyboard_arrow_down

    Jess Long - Kaizen Land - Gamifying Stand Up and Overcoming Anti Patterns

    Jess Long
    Jess Long
    Agile Coach
    Barclaycard US
    schedule 1 month ago
    Sold Out!
    40 mins
    Experience Report
    Intermediate

    Learn how the gingerbread men are taking over the daily Stand Up and forever changing the mornings of teams everywhere.

    Have your Daily Stand-Ups become stale? We’ll talk through the evolution of an idea that ended up demolishing monotony, obliterating anti-patterns and spawning smiles… and to think, it all started when my daughter and I were playing Candy Land!

    We’ll talk through the implementation of a game board during one team’s stand up through the infectious adoption and evolution of its existence. You’ll hear how teams tackled some of their greatest impediments and helped build a zone of psychological safety all while having fun.

    By the end of this session, you’ll be prepared to bring this back to your team and create your own success stories.